Current position > News detail
『Advantages and Disadvantages of Coriolis Flow Meter: Mass Sensor Sizing Rules』Related information(clamp on meter|electromagnetic meter|venturi meterrotameter|orifice meter|ultrasonic flow meter|mass flow meter|coriolis mass flow meter|coriolis flow meter|magnetic flow meter|magmeter flow meter|magflow flow meter|mag meter flow meter|electromagnetic flow meter|vortex flow meter|turbine flow meter|thermal mass flow meter|thermal flow meter|rotameter flow meter)
Advantages and Disadvantages of Coriolis Flow Meter: Mass Sensor Sizing Rules
Quick Answer: Coriolis flow meters measure mass flow directly with high accuracy for liquids, gases, and slurries. They have no moving parts and provide density and temperature outputs. The main disadvantages are higher purchase cost, pressure drop, and size limits above DN150. Correct mass sensor sizing rules prevent accuracy loss and excessive pressure drop.
Silver Instruments supplies Coriolis mass flow meters to industrial users in Southeast Asia, Oceania, Latin America, Africa, and the Middle East. We often get questions about advantages, disadvantages, and sizing rules. Here is the thing. Many engineers buy a Coriolis meter without checking pressure drop at operating viscosity. That mistake can turn a good project into a production problem.
Advantages of Coriolis Flow Meter
Coriolis meters measure mass flow directly. No need for temperature or pressure compensation for liquid mass measurement. Accuracy is high. A typical liquid accuracy is ±0.1% to ±0.2% of rate. Gas accuracy is ±0.5% of rate. The meter also outputs density and temperature. Density accuracy is often ±0.5 kg/m3 or better. Temperature output uses PT100 inside the sensor.
There are no moving parts. Maintenance is low compared to oval gear meters or turbine meters. A chemical plant in Vietnam replaced an oval gear meter on a resin line because the gears wore out after 14 months. The Coriolis meter has run for 3 years with no sensor repair. That is a real field result we have seen.
Coriolis meters handle viscous fluids, slurries, and liquids with entrained gas. Repeatability is good. Turndown ratio is often 20 to 1 or higher. This helps batching applications in food and beverage plants. The same meter can measure different products without recalibration because mass flow and density outputs are based on the sensor tubes.
The meters work in high pressure and high temperature processes. Standard options cover process connections up to PN40 or ANSI Class 300. High temperature remote electronics allow fluid temperatures up to 200 °C or more. ATEX Zone 1 and IECEx versions are available for hazardous areas.
Disadvantages of Coriolis Flow Meter
The purchase price is higher than an electromagnetic flow meter or a vortex flow meter. This is the main barrier for water and wastewater projects. A DN50 Coriolis meter costs more than a DN50 electromagnetic meter. We tell customers to compare total cost of ownership. If the fluid is expensive, viscous, or needs density data, the Coriolis meter often pays back in 12 to 24 months.
Pressure drop is a real concern. The flow passes through bent or straight sensor tubes with a restricted internal diameter. For a DN25 meter measuring heavy oil at 200 cP, pressure drop can exceed 0.5 bar at full flow. Sizing rules reduce this problem. But some engineers oversize the meter to lower pressure drop. That causes low flow velocity and accuracy loss.
Vibration sensitivity affects some installations. Large pumps, compressors, or nearby heavy equipment can introduce external vibration. Most modern Coriolis meters have digital signal processing to reject vibration. But site conditions still matter. A mining site in Western Australia had a Coriolis meter installed near a ball mill. The meter gave unstable readings until the piping support was improved.
Large line sizes are a limitation. Standard Coriolis meters are practical up to DN150 or DN200. Above that, the meter body becomes heavy and expensive. For a DN300 water line, an electromagnetic flow meter is usually a better choice. For DN300 fuel oil loading, we might use a smaller Coriolis meter on a bypass or a positive displacement meter.
Gas measurement requires careful sizing. Coriolis meters measure gas mass flow but gas has low density. The sensor needs enough mass flow to produce a stable signal. Low pressure gas below 2 bar can be difficult. We ask for gas molecular weight or density at operating conditions before quoting.
Mass Sensor Sizing Rules
Use mass flow rate for sizing. The unit is kg/h or kg/min. Do not size a Coriolis meter with volumetric flow only. Density of the fluid changes the volumetric flow. Water at 25 °C has a density of 997 kg/m3. A solvent at 0.79 kg/L has a very different mass flow for the same m3/h. Always convert to mass flow.
Check pressure drop at normal flow and maximum flow. Manufacturers provide pressure drop curves or software. Input viscosity in cP, density in kg/m3, and flow rate in kg/h. For liquids above 100 cP, pressure drop increases sharply. A rule of thumb is to keep liquid velocity inside the sensor between 0.5 m/s and 10 m/s. But the pressure drop calculation matters more than velocity.
<
Match the sensor size to the process pipe when possible. Common sizes are DN15, DN25, DN40, DN50, DN80, DN100, and DN150. A DN25 Coriolis meter can measure 0 to 3000 kg/h for water. A DN80 meter can handle up to 60000 kg/h depending on pressure drop. For a paint manufacturer in Southeast Asia measuring resin at 50 cP, we recommended a DN25 sensor for a flow range of 200 to 2000 kg/h. That kept pressure drop under 0.3 bar and accuracy better than ±0.15%.
For a DN25 line with water flow from 200 to 2000 kg/h, we recommend the SIL-CMF025 mass flow meter. For DN50 lines up to 30000 kg/h, the SIL-CMF050 works well. Both models include 4-20 mA HART and PT100 temperature output.
Do not oversize the meter. An oversized meter has low fluid velocity and low mass flow signal. Accuracy at low flow becomes worse. Turndown ratio helps but it cannot fix a meter that is too large. We have seen customers select DN80 for a flow of 300 kg/h. The meter barely registered. The correct choice was DN15 or DN20.
Do not undersize the meter either. A meter that is too small creates high pressure drop. A meter that is too small can also cause erosion or cavitation on low pressure applications. For demineralized water at 10 bar and 5000 kg/h, a DN20 may fit the flow range but pressure drop across the sensor could exceed 1.5 bar. A DN25 or DN40 would be better.
A desalination plant in Oman needed to measure antiscalant at 16 bar and 40 °C. The fluid had a density of 1.15 kg/L and viscosity of 3 cP. We recommended a DN15 SIL-CMF015 mass flow meter with a Hastelloy C sensor for a flow range of 10 to 100 kg/h. The unit has run for two years with no drift.
For gas sizing, include gas density at operating pressure and temperature. A Coriolis meter for natural gas at 8 bar will have a different sensor size than for nitrogen at 2 bar. Provide molecular weight or gas composition. In practice, most engineers skip this part and then wonder why low flow stability is poor.
Check fluid temperature and pressure ratings. Standard Coriolis sensors handle process temperatures from -50 °C to 200 °C. High temperature versions handle up to 350 °C. Process connections include flanged, threaded, and hygienic tri-clamp. Pressure ratings depend on the connection and sensor body. For a food beverage plant, we often supply DIN 11851 or tri-clamp connections on a stainless steel sensor.
Output options include 4-20 mA HART, pulse, and Modbus. We recommend 4-20 mA HART for most process control loops. The HART signal carries mass flow, density, and temperature. This allows remote monitoring without extra wiring. Silver Instruments configures the output range at the factory based on your flow range.
How to Request a Quote
Send us your pressure (bar), temperature (°C), pipe size (DN), and flow range in kg/h or m3/h. Include fluid name, density, and viscosity if available. For gas applications, include molecular weight or gas composition. Silver Automation Instruments will reply with a recommended model, sensor size, and price within 24 hours.
Contact us by phone or WhatsApp. Tel: +86-25-68650347. WhatsApp: +86-25-52155837. WeChat: +86 15365082610. Our website is flow-meter.com.au.
FAQ
1. What is the accuracy of a Coriolis flow meter?
Liquid mass flow accuracy is typically ±0.1% to ±0.2% of rate. Gas accuracy is ±0.5% of rate. Density accuracy is often ±0.5 kg/m3. Some models offer ±0.05% for custody transfer. Check the calibration certificate before commissioning.
2. Can a Coriolis flow meter measure gas?
Yes, Coriolis meters measure gas mass flow. But gas has low density and the meter needs enough mass flow. Low pressure gas below 2 bar may have poor low flow stability. Provide gas composition and operating pressure for proper sizing.
3. How do I size a Coriolis mass flow meter?
Use mass flow rate in kg/h. Check pressure drop at operating viscosity. Match sensor size to the process pipe. Do not oversize or undersize. Common sizes range from DN15 to DN150. Contact Silver Instruments with your flow range and fluid data.
4. What is the maximum pipe size for a Coriolis flow meter?
Standard Coriolis meters are practical up to DN150 or DN200. Larger line sizes are possible but heavy and expensive. For large water lines above DN200, electromagnetic flow meters are usually a better choice.
5. Does a Coriolis flow meter require straight pipe runs?
Coriolis meters do not require long straight pipe runs. Most models can be installed after elbows, valves, or pumps. This is a major advantage over vortex or ultrasonic meters. Follow the manufacturer minimum straight run recommendation for your specific model.